Skip to content
Bestsellers
Halloween
All Halloween Gifts
NEW! Halloween Night
NEW! Scaredy Cat
NEW! Monster Mash-Up
Pumpkins and Ghosts
Happy Halloween
Halloween Novelty
Fall
All Fall Gifts
NEW! Cozy Autumn
Fall Celebration
Watercolor Pumpkin
Fall Plaid
Seasonal
Ohio State University
Fall
Thanksgiving
Holiday
NEW! Winter Botanical
NEW! Gold Snowflake
NEW! Merry & Bright
Winter Deer
Tartan Plaid
Winter Snowflake
Let it Snow!
Winterberry
Novelty
Birthday
All Birthday Gifts
Celebration Collection
Best Wishes Collection
Thank You
All Thank You Gifts
NEW! Box of Thanks
Thanks For Being Awesome
Thanks! You're a Star
Thanks! Thanks!
Harlequin Thank You
Just The Cookies
Select Your Cookies
Shop by Occasion
SEASONAL GIFTS
Fall Gifts
Halloween Gifts
Thanksgiving Gifts
Holiday Gifts - Preorder Now!
EVERYDAY OCCASIONS
Baby
Birthday
College Care Packages
Congratulations
Everyday
Get Well Soon
Graduation
Sweet Smiles
Sympathy
Thank You
Thinking of You
Wedding
LICENSED PRODUCTS
Ohio State University
Shop by Gift
GIFT TYPE
Cookie Gift Boxes
Gift Stacks
Cookie Gift Tins
Gift Pails
Gift Bags
Bakery Gift Boxes
Half Dozen Samplers
Novelty Gifts
Mini Cubes
Duo Samplers
COOKIE ASSORTMENTS
Assorted Cookies
Iced Cookies
Select Your Cookies
Mini Cookies
Gluten Free & Vegan
Tea Gifts
Business Gifts
Holiday Business Gifts
Our Business Gift Solutions
Custom Logo Gifts
Customization options
Large Order Spreadsheet
Request a Quote
Upload Form
Sale
TRY US!
My Account
Search
CART
Your cart is empty
Continue shopping
Double Deal - 30% OFF + FREE SHIPPING til Midnight!
shop now
TRY US!
Sign In
(
0
) CART
(
0
) CART
Bestsellers
Halloween
All Halloween Gifts
NEW! Halloween Night
NEW! Scaredy Cat
NEW! Monster Mash-Up
Pumpkins and Ghosts
Happy Halloween
Halloween Novelty
Fall
All Fall Gifts
NEW! Cozy Autumn
Fall Celebration
Watercolor Pumpkin
Fall Plaid
Seasonal
Ohio State University
Fall
Thanksgiving
Holiday
NEW! Winter Botanical
NEW! Gold Snowflake
NEW! Merry & Bright
Winter Deer
Tartan Plaid
Winter Snowflake
Let it Snow!
Winterberry
Novelty
Birthday
All Birthday Gifts
Celebration Collection
Best Wishes Collection
Thank You
All Thank You Gifts
NEW! Box of Thanks
Thanks For Being Awesome
Thanks! You're a Star
Thanks! Thanks!
Harlequin Thank You
Just The Cookies
Select Your Cookies
Shop by Occasion
SEASONAL GIFTS
Fall Gifts
Halloween Gifts
Thanksgiving Gifts
Holiday Gifts - Preorder Now!
EVERYDAY OCCASIONS
Baby
Birthday
College Care Packages
Congratulations
Everyday
Get Well Soon
Graduation
Sweet Smiles
Sympathy
Thank You
Thinking of You
Wedding
LICENSED PRODUCTS
Ohio State University
Shop by Gift
GIFT TYPE
Cookie Gift Boxes
Gift Stacks
Cookie Gift Tins
Gift Pails
Gift Bags
Bakery Gift Boxes
Half Dozen Samplers
Novelty Gifts
Mini Cubes
Duo Samplers
COOKIE ASSORTMENTS
Assorted Cookies
Iced Cookies
Select Your Cookies
Mini Cookies
Gluten Free & Vegan
Tea Gifts
Business Gifts
Holiday Business Gifts
Our Business Gift Solutions
Custom Logo Gifts
Customization options
Large Order Spreadsheet
Request a Quote
Upload Form
Sale
Home
|
Gifts Under $40
Gifts Under $40
On sale
Holiday Ornament Duo Sampler - Iced Cookies
$9.99
$12.95
Default Title for $9.99
ADD TO BAG
Winter Snowflake Cookie Gift Box - Assorted Cookies
$35.95
Default Title for $35.95
ADD TO BAG
Let it Snow! Bakery Gift Box - Assorted Mini Cookies
$29.95
Default Title for $29.95
ADD TO BAG
Winter Deer Cookie Gift Boxes - Assorted Cookies
$35.95 - $169.95
Size:
12 Cookies (722)
12 Cookies (722) - $35.95
24 Cookies - $49.95
36 Cookies - $69.95
72 Cookies - $129.95
108 Cookies - $169.95
Size
12 Cookies (722)
24 Cookies
36 Cookies
72 Cookies
108 Cookies
12 Cookies (722) for $35.95
24 Cookies for $49.95
36 Cookies for $69.95
72 Cookies for $129.95
108 Cookies for $169.95
ADD TO BAG
Happy Birthday Gift Pail - Assorted Cookies
$39.95
Default Title for $39.95
ADD TO BAG
Thanks! Cookie Gift Boxes - Assorted Cookies
$35.95 - $69.95
Size:
12 Cookies (2958)
12 Cookies (2958) - $35.95
24 Cookies (2959) - $49.95
36 Cookies (2960) - $69.95
Size
12 Cookies (2958)
24 Cookies (2959)
36 Cookies (2960)
12 Cookies (2958) for $35.95
24 Cookies (2959) for $49.95
36 Cookies (2960) for $69.95
ADD TO BAG
Just the Cookies - Holiday Buttercream Iced Sugar Cookies
$30.95 - $50.95
Size:
12 COOKIES
12 COOKIES - $30.95
24 COOKIES - $40.95
36 COOKIES - $50.95
Size
12 COOKIES
24 COOKIES
36 COOKIES
12 COOKIES for $30.95
24 COOKIES for $40.95
36 COOKIES for $50.95
ADD TO BAG
Birthday Celebration Duo Sampler with Candles - Iced Cookies
$13.95
Default Title for $13.95
ADD TO BAG
Box of Thanks Gift Stack - Cookies and Snacks
$39.95
Default Title for $39.95
ADD TO BAG
Box of Thanks Half Dozen Sampler - Select Your Cookies
$24.95
Size:
6 Cookies
6 Cookies - $24.95
Size
6 Cookies
6 Cookies for $24.95
ADD TO BAG
Box of Thanks Half Dozen Sampler - Assorted Cookies
$23.95
Default Title for $23.95
ADD TO BAG
Box of Thanks Duo Sampler - Iced Cookies
$12.95
Default Title for $12.95
ADD TO BAG
Box of Thanks Duo Sampler - Assorted Cookies
$12.95
Default Title for $12.95
ADD TO BAG
Summer Garden Half Dozen Sampler - Assorted Cookies
$23.95
Default Title for $23.95
ADD TO BAG
On sale
Summer Garden Cookie Gift Boxes - Select Your Cookies
$33.11
$38.95
Size:
12 COOKIES (2662)
12 COOKIES (2662) - $33.11
24 COOKIES (2723) - $49.46
36 COOKIES (2725) - $68.36
Size
12 COOKIES (2662)
24 COOKIES (2723)
36 COOKIES (2725)
12 COOKIES (2662) for $33.11
24 COOKIES (2723) for $49.46
36 COOKIES (2725) for $68.36
ADD TO BAG
Box of Thanks Mini Cube Sampler - Assorted Mini Cookies
$19.95
Default Title for $19.95
ADD TO BAG
Just the Cookies! Thank You Assortment
$30.95 - $50.95
Size:
12 COOKIES
12 COOKIES - $30.95
24 COOKIES - $40.95
36 COOKIES - $50.95
Size
12 COOKIES
24 COOKIES
36 COOKIES
12 COOKIES for $30.95
24 COOKIES — SOLD OUT
36 COOKIES — SOLD OUT
ADD TO BAG
Vegan Gluten Free Cookies - Summer Garden Half Dozen Sampler
$28.95
Default Title for $28.95
ADD TO BAG
Thanks! Mini Cube Sampler - Assorted Mini Cookies
$19.95
Default Title for $19.95
ADD TO BAG
Purr-fect Half Dozen Sampler - Assorted Cookies
$23.95
Default Title for $23.95
ADD TO BAG
Just The Cookies - Signature Cookie Assortment
$29.95 - $49.95
Size:
12 COOKIES
12 COOKIES - $29.95
24 COOKIES - $39.95
36 COOKIES - $49.95
Size
12 COOKIES
24 COOKIES
36 COOKIES
12 COOKIES for $29.95
24 COOKIES for $39.95
36 COOKIES for $49.95
ADD TO BAG
Graduation Class of 2025 Mini Cube Sampler – Assorted Mini Cookies
$19.95
Default Title for $19.95
ADD TO BAG
Graduation Class of 2025 Duo Sampler - Assorted Cookies
$12.95
Default Title for $12.95
ADD TO BAG
Graduation Class of 2025 Half Dozen Sampler – Assorted Cookies
$23.95
Default Title for $23.95
ADD TO BAG
1
…
7
8
9
10
11
…
16
SEARCH BY TYPING IN THE SEARCH BOX BELOW.
