Skip to content
Bestsellers
New Year's
Holiday
NEW! Winter Snowflake
Winterberry
Silver & Gold Snowflake
Winter Deer
Tartan Plaid
Let It Snow!
Evergreen Trees
Novelty & Tins
All Holiday Gifts
Select Your Cookies
Gluten Free
OSU
Thank You
Thanks For Being Awesome
Thanks! You're a Star
Thanks! Thanks!
Harlequin Thank You
ALL Thank You Gifts
Birthday
Celebration Collection
Best Wishes Collection
All Birthday Gifts
Just The Cookies
Occasions
HOLIDAY GIFTS
Holiday Gifts
New Year's Gifts
EVERYDAY OCCASIONS
Baby
Birthday
College Care Packages
Congratulations
Everyday
Get Well Soon
Gluten Free & Vegan
Sympathy
Thank You
The Michael J. Fox Foundation
Thinking of You
Wedding
LICENSED PRODUCTS
Ohio State University
Cincinnati Bengals
Business Gifts
Our Business Gift Solutions
Shop Best Sellers
Custom Logo Gifts
Customization options
Large Order Spreadsheet
Request a Quote
Upload Form
Sale
TRY US!
My Account
Search
CART
Your cart is empty
Continue shopping
Limited Time! $5 SHIPPING SITEWIDE with code FIVE
shop now
TRY US!
Sign In
(
0
) CART
(
0
) CART
Bestsellers
New Year's
Holiday
NEW! Winter Snowflake
Winterberry
Silver & Gold Snowflake
Winter Deer
Tartan Plaid
Let It Snow!
Evergreen Trees
Novelty & Tins
All Holiday Gifts
Select Your Cookies
Gluten Free
OSU
Thank You
Thanks For Being Awesome
Thanks! You're a Star
Thanks! Thanks!
Harlequin Thank You
ALL Thank You Gifts
Birthday
Celebration Collection
Best Wishes Collection
All Birthday Gifts
Just The Cookies
Occasions
HOLIDAY GIFTS
Holiday Gifts
New Year's Gifts
EVERYDAY OCCASIONS
Baby
Birthday
College Care Packages
Congratulations
Everyday
Get Well Soon
Gluten Free & Vegan
Sympathy
Thank You
The Michael J. Fox Foundation
Thinking of You
Wedding
LICENSED PRODUCTS
Ohio State University
Cincinnati Bengals
Business Gifts
Our Business Gift Solutions
Shop Best Sellers
Custom Logo Gifts
Customization options
Large Order Spreadsheet
Request a Quote
Upload Form
Sale
Home
|
Gifts Under $40
Gifts Under $40
Birthday Celebration Cookie Gift Box - Select Your Cookies
$38.95
Size:
12 cookies
12 cookies - $38.95
Size
12 cookies
12 cookies for $38.95
ADD TO BAG
You’re a Star Half Dozen Sampler - Assorted Cookies
$23.95
Default Title for $23.95
ADD TO BAG
Harlequin Cookie Gift Tin - Assorted Mini Cookies
$24.95
Default Title for $24.95
ADD TO BAG
Thanks Cookie Gift Boxes - Select Your Cookies
$38.95 - $74.95
Size:
12 Cookies (2103)
12 Cookies (2103) - $38.95
24 Cookies (2106) - $54.95
36 Cookies (2109) - $74.95
Size
12 Cookies (2103)
24 Cookies (2106)
36 Cookies (2109)
12 Cookies (2103) for $38.95
24 Cookies (2106) for $54.95
36 Cookies (2109) for $74.95
ADD TO BAG
Just The Cookies - Buttercream Iced Sugar Cookies
$30.95 - $50.95
Size:
12 COOKIES
12 COOKIES - $30.95
24 COOKIES - $40.95
36 COOKIES - $50.95
Size
12 COOKIES
24 COOKIES
36 COOKIES
12 COOKIES for $30.95
24 COOKIES for $40.95
36 COOKIES for $50.95
ADD TO BAG
Hang In There Mini Cube Sampler - Assorted Mini Cookies
$19.95
Default Title for $19.95
ADD TO BAG
Thank You Cookie Gift Boxes - Select Your Cookies
$38.95 - $179.95
Size:
12 Cookies (325)
12 Cookies (325) - $38.95
24 Cookies (326) - $54.95
36 Cookies (327) - $74.95
72 Cookies (328) - $139.95
108 Cookies (329) - $179.95
Size
12 Cookies (325)
24 Cookies (326)
36 Cookies (327)
72 Cookies (328)
108 Cookies (329)
12 Cookies (325) for $38.95
24 Cookies (326) for $54.95
36 Cookies (327) for $74.95
72 Cookies (328) for $139.95
108 Cookies (329) for $179.95
ADD TO BAG
Congratulations Gift Stack - Cookies and Brownies
$39.95
Default Title for $39.95
ADD TO BAG
Thanks for Being Awesome Cookie Gift Boxes - Assorted Cookies
$35.95 - $69.95
Size:
12 Cookies
12 Cookies - $35.95
24 Cookies - $49.95
36 Cookies - $69.95
Size
12 Cookies
24 Cookies
36 Cookies
12 Cookies for $35.95
24 Cookies for $49.95
36 Cookies for $69.95
ADD TO BAG
Harlequin Cookie Gift Tin - Assorted Cookies
$39.95
Default Title for $39.95
ADD TO BAG
Birthday Wishes Cookie Gift Boxes - Select Your Cookies
$38.95 - $74.95
Size:
12 Cookies (2385)
12 Cookies (2385) - $38.95
24 Cookies (2386) - $54.95
36 Cookies (2387) - $74.95
Size
12 Cookies (2385)
24 Cookies (2386)
36 Cookies (2387)
12 Cookies (2385) for $38.95
24 Cookies (2386) for $54.95
36 Cookies (2387) for $74.95
ADD TO BAG
College Care Luxe Cookie Gift Box - Assorted Mini Cookies
$39.95
Size:
1 tag (2716)
1 tag (2716) - $39.95
Size
1 tag (2716)
1 tag (2716) for $39.95
ADD TO BAG
Hug From Home Duo Cookie Sampler - Assorted Cookies
$10.95
Default Title for $10.95
ADD TO BAG
Hug From Home Half Dozen Sampler - Assorted Cookies
$23.95
Default Title for $23.95
ADD TO BAG
College Care Mini Cube Sampler - Assorted Mini Cookies
$19.95
Default Title for $19.95
ADD TO BAG
You’re a Star Cookie Gift Box - Assorted Cookies
$35.95
Default Title for $35.95
ADD TO BAG
Thanks Half Dozen Sampler - Assorted Cookies
$23.95
Default Title for $23.95
ADD TO BAG
Birthday Cookie Decorating Kit
$39.95
Default Title for $39.95
ADD TO BAG
Thank You Cookie Gift Boxes - Assorted Cookies
$35.95 - $169.95
Size:
12 Cookies
12 Cookies - $35.95
24 Cookies - $49.95
36 Cookies - $69.95
72 Cookies - $129.95
108 Cookies - $169.95
Size
12 Cookies
24 Cookies
36 Cookies
72 Cookies
108 Cookies
12 Cookies for $35.95
24 Cookies for $49.95
36 Cookies for $69.95
72 Cookies for $129.95
108 Cookies for $169.95
ADD TO BAG
Cookies Are Best When Shared Duo Cookie Sampler - Assorted Cookies
$10.95
Default Title for $10.95
ADD TO BAG
Just The Cookies - All Chocolate Chip Cookies
$29.95 - $49.95
Size:
12 COOKIES
12 COOKIES - $29.95
24 COOKIES - $39.95
36 COOKIES - $49.95
Size
12 COOKIES
24 COOKIES
36 COOKIES
12 COOKIES for $29.95
24 COOKIES for $39.95
36 COOKIES for $49.95
ADD TO BAG
Every Occasion Gift Box - Assorted Mini Cookies
$29.95
Default Title for $29.95
ADD TO BAG
Harlequin Cookie Gift Boxes - Assorted Cookies
$35.95 - $169.95
Size:
12 Cookies
12 Cookies - $35.95
24 Cookies - $49.95
36 Cookies - $69.95
72 Cookies - $129.95
108 Cookies - $169.95
Size
12 Cookies
24 Cookies
36 Cookies
72 Cookies
108 Cookies
12 Cookies for $35.95
24 Cookies for $49.95
36 Cookies for $69.95
72 Cookies for $129.95
108 Cookies for $169.95
ADD TO BAG
Birthday Celebration Gift Tin - Assorted Mini Cookies
$24.95
Default Title for $24.95
ADD TO BAG
1
2
3
…
7
SEARCH BY TYPING IN THE SEARCH BOX BELOW.